
The Road to Nashville, The Heart of a Worship Pastor, and Dependence on God | Chris Clayton
Producer and Songwriter, Chris Clayton, joins the guys to talk about his journey to Nashville and his love for the music industry. Chris shares his journey of faith and career in the music industry, highlighting the importance of taking risks and trusting God’s guidance. He encourages aspiring musicians to invest in their craft, build relationships, and be patient with the process. Ultimately, Chris emphasizes the importance of aligning one’s steps with God’s plan and finding fulfillment in making an impact rather than just seeking success.
https://www.chrisclaytonmusic.com
https://www.instagram.com/chrisclaytonmusic
https://www.facebook.com/chrismclayton78
https://twitter.com/chrismclayton
Leave us a voicemail online and send us your experience or thoughts to info@notquitethereshow.com
Visit nqtshow.com and visit here to see all available platforms this podcast is now available on!
How do you follow God into a calling with no clear-cut path? Nashville producer and songwriter Chris Clayton’s answer is one obedient step at a time, trusting the Lord to confirm each yes, because “the heart of man plans his way, but the Lord establishes his steps.” Chris, a longtime friend of the show from their days at 121, joins Mike Mobley and Chris Howard to tell his story: from seeing Slash on MTV in Beaumont, Texas, to a $600-a-month studio internship, getting kicked out of the nest, the move to Nashville that his wife Kara sensed first, six and a half years as a worship pastor, and stepping back into full-time production. He also covers how he handles doubt, the myths about making it in music, the return of vertical worship songs, and what makes a worship pastor different from a worship leader. Below: the key takeaways, the Scripture discussed, and the full episode transcript.
From a Credits Junkie to Nashville
Chris discovered guitar the summer his family moved to Beaumont, Texas, and his grandmother bought him his first one. By 10th grade, he knew he wanted to produce and write songs. He was a credits junkie who cared more about the names behind the records than the artists on the cover. He planned to transfer from Dallas Baptist University to Belmont, but he met Kara and stayed. Looking back, he says he would not have been ready for Nashville then. Their first 16 years as a family were in Dallas, where he started as an intern at a friend’s studio for $600 a month.
Kicked Out of the Nest, Then Confirmed
The pivotal moment came when his boss, David, told him he was worth more than the studio could pay and pushed him out to build his own clientele, while giving him a room rent free. Their first thought was money. Within weeks, a friend gave them a car they didn’t think they needed, so Chris sold his own car to buy his first computer, Pro Tools and a microphone. He calls it one of many confirmations. God was saying, “I just need you to say yes to this, and I will keep showing you that the yes is the right move.” Years later, Kara sensed the call to Nashville months before Chris brought it up.
Holy Discontent and Daily Doubt
Every faith step has started with a holy discontent: God is moving ahead, so we need to follow. Leaving his church staff role meant giving up relationships and financial security. As Chris puts it, “I’ve read enough about disobedience in the Old Testament to know when God calls you to something, you should probably do it.” Doubt still shows up daily, especially in a year of big change. His answer is staying consistent in the Word, talking it out with people he trusts, and praying for God to align his path and give him blinders. The doubt fades when he sees his family thriving where God led them.
He Establishes Our Steps
Mike shares that Proverbs 16:9 has become a banner verse for him. The older he gets, the more trusting God shrinks down to today, even to the next hour, instead of having the next 30 years figured out. Chris says he grew to hate the question “What’s your five-year plan?” because life with God is a daily dependence. His banner song is “Lord, I Need You,” with its line “Teach my song to rise to You.” Chris Howard adds that there is never a day to tell God, “I’ve got it from here.”
Myths and Truths About Making It in Music
Chris says the first myth is that you need formal education. The gear is more accessible than ever, and kids are making radio records in their bedrooms. The real investment is relationships, showing up consistently, and putting thousands of hours into your craft. Nashville is a seven- to 10-year town. He has found more community than competition there, and you don’t have to live in Nashville to make a living. Mature artists are driven to make an impact, not just to make it. And your journey won’t look like anyone else’s, because there’s no magic formula.
Vertical Songs and Portable Theology
Chris is encouraged to see independent artists like Forrest Frank reaching Christian radio, and to see churches coming back to vertical songs that lift up God’s holiness and majesty, especially after COVID. Those are the legacy songs, like “Holy, Holy, Holy” and “How Great Thou Art.” A worship leader can be pastoral, but a worship pastor shepherds on and off the stage. Songs are “portable theology.” People remember them longer than sermons, so they had better be rich in doctrine. A four- or five-song set is really four or five mini sermons, and when life falls apart on a Tuesday, the worship pastor is in the trenches too.
Scriptures From This Episode
Proverbs 16:9 (“The heart of man plans his way, but the Lord establishes his steps”)
Also referenced: “throwing out a fleece” (Gideon, Judges 6) and the Old Testament stories of disobedience.
Go deeper: Proverbs 16: The Lord Establishes You · Seeing God Work Through Obedience · Why Taking Steps Is A Godly Thing · Depending on God · Keep Trusting Even When You Can’t See · 10 Ways Why We Worship The Way We Do
Full Transcript, Not Quite There, Episode 14: The Road to Nashville, The Heart of a Worship Pastor, and Dependence on God | Chris Clayton
Chris Clayton: Knowing to be obedient to what the Lord has asked us to do far outweighed that. I always kind of joke, I’ve read enough about disobedience in the Old Testament to know when God calls you to something, you should probably do it.
Chris: Hey, Michael, how you doing today?
Mike: Oh, Michael, the full first name. Thank you. Thank you, Christian.
Chris: We can get formal at times here.
Mike: We’re very formal here on NQT. That’s what people know us as.
Chris: Absolutely. I think you and I need to get some tuxedo shirts and just kind of dress this up a little bit for the people.
Mike: Why do shirts when we can do the real tux?
Chris: We can do the real tux. You want to do the Dumb and Dumber tuxes, or have those been overdone?
Mike: If we do Dumb and Dumber, I’m going to go with the orange one. I think you would look great in light blue. It would bring out the color of your eyes.
Chris: My brown eyes? I hear that often. Yes. Thank you. Yeah, we need to dress it up a little bit. Go ahead. You ask the questions here, buddy.
Mike: Oh, sure. Okay. I’m sorry I spoke over you. I just, you know, want to know how your day was and how life has been. I’m just trying to get to know my co-host, Chris.
Chris: Yeah. So, life: good. Day: good. I’m glad to be here with you. Of course, it’s always a treat whenever we get to do this. What I really like is dogs barking in the background.
Mike: Sorry about that.
Chris: It reminds me that, yeah, I have a lawnmower going out here too, that started up at an opportune time.
Mike: I can’t hear your lawnmower, but the fact that you can hear my dog is a very concerning situation. But that’s okay.
Chris: Maybe the dog’s a fan of the show. Just excited.
Mike: This is real life. You know what? We’re not always going to cut everything. Sometimes there’s a dog in the background. That is what life is.
Chris: This is life. You’re looking at it. You’re listening to it. Well, listeners aren’t looking at it, but they’re listening to it. Hopefully they are. One of the things that I’m finding kind of remarkable is that here we are in the middle of summer, Michael, and we are experiencing 70 degree weather, 80 degree weather. Usually it’s melt-your-tires hot here in Texas, but we’re making it. We’re getting by. We’re getting some rain.
Mike: You know, Christian, I agree on the temperature of the summer. Apparently we really are keeping with the formalities today. So, speaking of formal, sometimes when you think formal and tuxedo, some would even say presidential. It makes you think of the guest that we have today. We have another guest today. Just a spoiler alert right there. Wouldn’t you say formal is probably a theme that comes to mind for you, co-host Chris?
Chris: I would say formal. And since we’re talking about formal and we’re talking about weather, and weather is a formal subject, usually something that kind of just opens things up, you shoot the breeze about it when you don’t know what else to talk about…
Mike: You’re going to keep talking about the weather.
Chris: I’m going to talk about the cool breeze that kind of just blows in here from Nashville, in the form of Chris Clayton. I think he’s responsible for maybe some of the good weather we’re having just by joining us here today.
Mike: Chris Clayton, all the way from Nashville. The man who likes to grill, the man who’s been involved in worship, the man who has a big family, the man who wears a hat almost every day: it’s Chris Clayton himself. Everyone, come on in the studio. Chris, welcome.
Chris Clayton: Hey, I am very delighted to be here. I’m just not worthy to hang out with you after that banter.
Mike: That crazy banter about the weather. Yeah. That really went to a whole other level.
Chris Clayton: Michael and Christian. I’m glad to be here. It’s good to see you.
Chris: Glad to have you, Christopher.
Chris Clayton: That is my legal name. That is the legal name.
Mike: Christopher G. Allen.
Chris Clayton: Yeah, exactly. It is a nice day here in Nashville. I think it got up to 83 today, with a little bit of a breeze from the southwest and a chance of rain tonight.
Mike: Well, we’re four minutes in and we’ve talked about the weather way too much. No one’s going to listen to this anymore. But if you’re still with us, thank you very much. We really appreciate that.
Chris Clayton: Glad to be here.
Mike: We’re excited to have you too, for real. For context for everyone, we’ve all been friends for a long time now, and I think God’s just put it on our hearts to have you come on and be a guest. We just want to hear from you. But before we get into anything too heavy, we do have a couple of what we’re going to call appetizer questions. Not quite the lightning round, just a couple of appetizers. Coach Chris, do you want me to go for these?
Chris: Sure. Who doesn’t love an appetizer, right?
Mike: Who doesn’t love a good old appetizer? Some cheese sticks…
Chris: Some potato skins. You guys did not sound excited for potato skins. Is that too eighties? Is that too Chili’s?
Mike: I just thought you were going to say something else, and then nothing.
Chris: I thought you guys might like the goodness of carbs loaded with bacon.
Chris Clayton: It is dinner time.
Mike: Yes, that’s good. It’s never too early for dinner. Okay, here we go. Don’t overthink this. Star Wars, Lord of the Rings, or Harry Potter?
Chris Clayton: Star Wars.
Mike: What was your first job?
Chris Clayton: I worked for a copier company. I sold copiers.
Mike: Oh, a copier guy. I’m making copies. Do you speak any other languages?
Chris Clayton: No. A little bit of Spanish, but not enough to say I know it.
Mike: Do you know “¿Dónde está María?”
Chris Clayton: El baño? No, I don’t know.
Chris: We’ve covered this one extensively on this show.
Mike: She’s always in the library.
Chris Clayton: I don’t remember this one.
Mike: Okay. What’s a place you’ve been to that you absolutely loved?
Chris Clayton: Bigfork, Montana.
Mike: Is it known for, like, a utensil? Is it the home of the fork, or what?
Chris Clayton: Just gorgeous mountains. Just amazing. That’s what comes to mind first.
Mike: So was that just a vacation, and it was beautiful countryside?
Chris Clayton: No, I went on a songwriting trip up there. That had to be four or five years ago. It was a week of songwriting, just up in the mountains in a cabin.
Chris: That sounds amazing.
Mike: I kind of want to go to Bigfork. I wonder why it’s called Bigfork, but that’s another podcast.
Chris: All right. So this is where we pivot. We’re taking a turn. We’re not going to play around with weather and little questions. We’re going to dive in and get into who this Chris Clayton is. Get down to the nitty gritty. Why don’t you just give us an overview, tell us a little bit about where you’re at now, tell us a little bit about your family, whatever you want, and then we’ll dive into some hard-hitting questions.
Chris Clayton: My family and I have been in Nashville coming up on eight years. It’ll be eight years this October, which still feels like yesterday that we moved here, honestly, some days. I’m the husband of Kara. We are coming up on 24 years in January, and we have five kids. Four boys. Corbin’s 20. He is a young man doing his thing. He is full time on the road as a lighting director for a band called We Are Messengers, and does stuff for a band called CAIN as well, and other artists. Super proud of him and what he’s doing right now. We never see him because he’s always on a bus or a plane somewhere. It’s crazy. Then Callen is 19, almost 20. He works for a landscaping company, loves to work with his hands and get dirty, and loves the smell of manure in the morning. He’s just one of those kids. Cade loves missions and has really been bit by the bug of going on mission trips, so I’m anxious to see where the Lord has for him. Then there’s Cohen. He is baseball through and through and just loves playing baseball. And then our little girl, Kambree. She is a firecracker personality, and just a joy and a miracle in herself. I am the owner of a dog, and now a cat, apparently.
Mike: Apparently? As in, you just found that out?
Chris Clayton: Well, it just showed up under the Christmas tree this past year. So now there’s Maverick. He’s the cat. I like him. He comes and sits near my face in my bed sometimes and wakes me up at night, but he’s fine.
Chris: Well, if you’re going to have a cat, you need a cat with a cool name.
Chris Clayton: So it’s Maverick. Our dog’s name is Bandit and our cat’s name is Maverick.
Mike: That’s perfect. Who doesn’t want an animal to sit on your face and wake you up in the middle of the night? That’s just love. It’s what you want.
Chris: Well, Chris, while you recounted your family there, it makes me feel pretty old, because we’ve traveled quite a few years together, and those kids have grown up kind of in front of our eyes. The Claytons were just known for cute Clayton kids, one after the other. You had four boys there for the longest time, and then Kambree. That’s been neat to see your family just grow. And of course, we had you in Dallas-Fort Worth for quite a while at 121, and that’s where you and I met. I believe that’s where you and Mike met as well.
Mike: I would stake my claim that we met there, but we also grew up on the streets together. A bunch of black market situations, and just a lot of tough love as friends.
Chris Clayton: We’ve been on the set of Days of Our Lives.
Mike: There it is. There it is.
Chris Clayton: Passions, whatever it was.
Chris: That’s another story in itself.
Chris Clayton: That’s another story in itself. We don’t need to get into that right now.
Mike: You know what, hold on. I have a question before we get going. You have four boys and one girl. I only have one boy and one girl, so I’m not really a parent compared to you. Well done and congratulations. But now that you have a girl, what’s a big difference for you between all boys and now a girl?
Chris Clayton: The first thing that comes to mind is the emotional state of the kids. With boys, you can be a little rough and tough, even just in how you interact. Not physically, and not slandering them, but just how you talk to them, you know? And I remember telling Kambree when she was little the word “no,” because she was doing something bad. I said, “Kambree, no, don’t do that.” And just alligator tears started flowing. I froze. I didn’t know what to do. And I looked over at Kara, and she’s just laughing at me. She’s like, “You have to white glove this a little bit, bud.” So I’ve learned that I have to white glove it, and come at it a little more gracefully, even with just the word no.
Mike: That’s a good word. We’ve noticed those differences too, because like you said, I can be rough and tough with Matthew. Not mean rough, it’s just different. And then the exact same phrase with Peyton, it’s like, okay, this does not communicate well to both genders at the same time. So anyway, it’s awesome.
Chris: Well, having a daughter and just a daughter… why say just a daughter? Oh, what a wonderful daughter I have. You have to walk that tightrope every time. So there’s no rough and tumble in my world, but that’s wonderful. Chris, you and I used to serve on the creative team a long time ago at 121. That’s where I got to meet you. And of course, you were serving on the worship team. The first time I ever saw you was up on stage singing one of your songs. And it’s been neat to see the things that you’ve done since then, making music and producing music. Your career. How did you know that music was going to be it for you? Was there a moment where you saw the guitar up on the shelf and said, “That’s got to be my buddy for the rest of these years”? What was that seminal moment?
Chris Clayton: I don’t think there was really a specific moment where I went, “That’s what I’m going to do.” The only thing I can think of is, I grew up in Beaumont, Texas, down in Southeast Texas. I went to high school there. My dad pastored down there for years. And I remember we got cable, and we had MTV for the very first time. I didn’t grow up with MTV, and I discovered bands and music. That summer that we moved to Beaumont, I just discovered guitar and found I love that. Specifically, I saw Slash standing on top of a piano during “November Rain,” and I was like, “I want to play guitar.” Not with the top hat, but I want to play guitar. And my grandmother, who just passed away earlier this year at 101, bought me my very first guitar. That’s what kind of set everything in motion. And then I discovered our local Christian radio station in Beaumont. I started going to every concert they put on and just fell in love more with not just music, but specifically Christian music. And growing up in the church, I started leading worship in my youth group. By 10th grade, I knew I wanted to be a producer and a songwriter. I didn’t know how that was going to look. I didn’t know how to even become that. But I just knew I wanted to move to this magical town called Nashville one day and start making records. We can get more into my story later if you want, but I kind of gave up on that dream a little bit, and then it came back full circle years later. But it was high school when I really knew I wanted to do this.
Mike: Wow. I mean, besides the obvious top hat draw, because who doesn’t love a good top hat? You’re ingesting all this music, and Christian music, and in 10th grade you’re saying music producer. Why? I love music, too, and I haven’t felt a call to produce it or anything like that. What is it about that that speaks to you?
Chris Clayton: I think it’s the challenge, and just the idea of melding musical parts together that make a song, and the emotion that it evokes out of people when it all comes together. That was intriguing to me. I’m a credits junkie. I would always look at credits to see who produced it, who played on it, who mixed it, who mastered it, who wrote the songs. Those names were almost more intriguing to me than the actual artists at times, because I would see these same names over and over again. I would see the studios. I would see towns like Franklin and towns like Nashville, towns that I now live in, and I was like, there’s got to be something that happens in these towns with these people. It’s more the behind-the-scenes of things versus being the stage guy. And yes, I spent many years on a platform leading worship, but even in the season I’m in now, I feel much more comfortable behind this desk that I’m sitting at than I do on a platform. I love encouraging other artists and other worship leaders. Maybe it’s just the season of life I’m now in. There was a season where I was making my own records and writing my own songs, for me. But I don’t even have a desire to do that anymore. It’s more about the behind the scenes and helping other artists do what they do.
Chris: So, two great revelations for me there. Number one, Mike, I think we found our new look, with the top hat and the tuxedo shirts.
Mike: I already bought one off Amazon, actually, right now. It was a value pack. It was a two pack. Don’t worry.
Chris: Nice. Make sure it’s a smedium, so it’s going to fit really nice. But Chris, I didn’t really know that Nashville was in your sights early on, and it’s been really neat to know it’s come full circle like that. I don’t think there’s a book called How to Get to Nashville and Do What You Dream About Doing. One of the things we talk about on this show is taking one step at a time and just moving forward. But without a clear-cut path, how would you describe that journey of just taking steps to get there?
Chris Clayton: I’ll give you the Reader’s Digest version of the steps. It’s been a lot. I went to Dallas Baptist University there in Dallas, and the goal was just to go a couple of years and then transfer to Belmont University, which is here in Nashville. I wanted to major in commercial music. I ended up meeting this girl at DBU. We dated all through college and I ended up marrying her. So I ended up staying the whole time at DBU because I met Kara, and I just knew that was part of my journey versus going to Belmont. And honestly, looking back, I wouldn’t have been ready for Nashville when I wanted to go to Nashville, knowing what I know now about how this whole town and industry works. There’s plenty that come to Belmont or a college out here and do that. But for me personally, where I was at spiritually and emotionally, I would have been back in Texas pretty soon, probably. So we graduated, we got married right out of college, and our first 16 years of life as a family were there in Dallas. I worked at a studio with our friend David forever. That was a big step, to step into that role. I stepped into it as an intern, making like $600 a month. It was pennies. But back then it felt like a ton of money, because I was doing what I loved to do. It didn’t matter about the money. I was in the environment. I was meeting people. I still have relationships with some of the people that I met through that whole experience. And probably the most pivotal moment was when David sat me down and said, “Hey, your value is worth more than what I can pay you and what the opportunity is here now. So I’m basically kicking you out of the nest, and you need to go fly.” I’ll never forget going home to our apartment, and Kara was pregnant with Callen, our second kid, and going, “I think I lost my job today.” But David was so gracious, because he gave me our Studio B rent free. Basically, “You supply the gear, I’ll give you the room for free, but you’ve got to start building clientele.” It was the best thing that could ever happen to me, honestly, because it forced me to not lean on him for my career building, but to actually go out and do it myself and start grinding. That was a big faith step, because we weren’t made of money. I sold a car to go buy my first computer and Pro Tools, which is the program that I use, and a microphone. That’s how it all started. It was like, okay, we’ve got to figure this out, because this is not going to come together on its own. And then as far as the Nashville move, that was eight years ago. I felt the Lord was saying our time in Dallas was ending and there were more opportunities coming out here. I’d signed my first publishing deal, and I started making trips out here for work. I think I made five trips in nine months, and I was like, this is getting ridiculous. A, it’s getting expensive, and B, there are more relationships and opportunities here. I always say that the grace kind of lifted from Dallas and planted in Nashville. And gosh, we have so many great friends like you guys that are still there. But it was so clear and evident. In fact, Kara knew we were supposed to go before I really knew. She had felt like the Lord had spoken that to her, but she never said anything to me. Then I came to her one day and said, “I think we need to move to Nashville.” And she just started crying. And I was like, “Nope, we’re not supposed to move.” And she said, “I’ve been waiting for you to tell me that for three months.” She had come on a work trip here with me and felt like the Holy Spirit spoke to her and said, “You’re going to love it here one day. You’re going to move here, and you’re going to love it.” So fast forward, we’re here, and it’s just been a continued journey of faith. I was on staff at a church here in the Franklin area for six and a half years, which was not even on the radar. In fact, I told the Lord, “Please do not put me on staff at a church in Nashville. I just want one job for once in my life.” And He gave me about four months, and I found myself on staff with my friend Michael Farren, on the worship staff, as an associate worship pastor. A year and a half later, Michael rolled off and I came on as lead worship pastor, all the while still doing production and songwriting. So it was a big balancing act in terms of time and mental capacity and emotional capacity. Both of y’all know there’s no such thing as a part-time pastor. I walked with that church for six and a half years. And then, not even a year ago, back in August of last year, we stepped down from there, another faith step in the journey, to go back into production and songwriting full time. Both trajectories in those years at Gateway were growing. The church was growing, and my career as a producer and songwriter was up and to the right on the chart. Nothing was bad on either front. It was just that the Lord said that assignment’s done, and it’s time to take a step into this. I was just sharing with a guy today at lunch that this has honestly been my favorite year of being here so far, in terms of growth and relationships and opportunities. One thing the Lord said specifically when He called us away was, “You’ve been in the safe space for too long, and I need you to walk out of it so that I can take you places that are going to blow your mind.” The journey still continues day by day, but it’s been a fun one.
Mike: What I love about that is, you have quite a bit of experience under your belt now, and we’re all a little bit older. We’re not as old as co-host Chris, but…
Chris: I was waiting for it.
Mike: But you’ve had these moments. I know it sounds easy, and I know it’s not easy, but it’s like, okay, the Lord’s clearly wrapped up this assignment. I’m over here in Dallas, I kind of get kicked out of the nest, and now you’re looking back going, “That was the greatest thing for me.” Could you talk a little bit about that process? Whatever the next thing is the Lord has for us, or for anyone listening who might be getting kicked out of the nest right now, it’s got to feel hard in the moment. By now you’re at the point of going, “This was amazing for me,” but I would imagine on day two, waking up, you weren’t going, “This is incredible that I think I lost my job.” How did you handle that?
Chris Clayton: I think the biggest thing for us was, our first mindset went to money. It was like, we need the basic needs met. So what do we have to do? And a quick story: I live by confirmations of when the Lord works, whether it’s conversations or things we read or whatever. I feel like every faith step in our journey has been overly confirmed. And I’ve even asked the Lord multiple times, “All right, Lord, I’m going to throw out one more fleece, unless You soak that one too.” I just keep throwing out the fleece. But one quick story: early on, when I got kicked out of the nest of David’s world on the studio side, it had to have been within the first few weeks, someone that we both know, I won’t mention names, approached me and said, “I’ve got a car for you,” and gave Kara and me a car. We actually didn’t need a car. I tried to fight it. I was like, “I don’t need a car.” He goes, “No, I think you need a car.” And we took the car, and I sold my car and bought Pro Tools and a computer and my microphone with it, because I could make more money off my car than if I were to sell the other car, and the other car was still in great condition for us to use. At that time, my car was one of my biggest assets to sell to actually get into this thing, and yet we still weren’t left stranded without a vehicle. It’s been confirmations like that, where I wake up the next day going, the Lord has us, because He’s seen not only our daily needs, but the big 30,000-foot needs of what we need to get going. I feel like that’s just one of many confirmations over our family’s life of seeing the Lord go, “Okay, I just need you to say yes to this, and I will keep showing you that the yes is the right move, if you’ll just trust Me.”
Mike: Wow. So it’s that continual… not that you’re getting a car every single day, which would be awesome… but it’s that continual, day-to-day paying attention to what the Lord’s doing, how He’s affirming y’all’s direction one way or the other, and just continuing to take steps. Now we have the hindsight of looking back over years, but when you drill it down, where do you see the Lord working in your life each day? And how is He speaking to you? Because we know He’s there talking. We’re just not necessarily listening all the time.
Chris Clayton: I think one common denominator in every faith step is we’ve always had a little bit of discontent with where we’ve been. Not discontent as in not happy. It’s more of a holy discontent: God’s moving ahead of us, so we need to move. We need to follow Him. And as hard as it’s been sometimes to take that step… gosh, it was hard to leave Gateway, where we spent six and a half years on staff, for a lot of reasons. One, the relationships that we had built. While we still live in the same town, we knew it was going to look different, and it has looked different, and we’re not mad about that. We knew that going into it. It’s just a different rhythm of life with those relationships. So we knew that would be on the altar, giving that up. And financially, it was a big change for us, because there was a lot of security in that. It wasn’t enough money for us to live on wholly, but it was a great chunk for us to count on every month. So even walking away from that… we knew what we were getting into, but the call, and knowing to be obedient to what the Lord has asked us to do, far outweighed that. I always kind of joke, I’ve read enough about disobedience in the Old Testament to know when God calls you to something, you should probably do it.
Chris: That’s good. You build up these faith muscles, I guess we can call them, as you see these opportunities, and you see the doubt, and there’s a comfort that can come along with that too. One of the things we’ve been talking about recently is when it seems like God is silent, or it seems like you’re waiting on something to happen or wanting something to happen. Certainly that causes doubt and discomfort. So maybe dive in a little there. Okay, this is another chance to be faithful here. This is another chance to pray. But how do you see that play out day to day? What are you doing to keep yourself there and aligned with God?
Mike: Also, after you answer this question, we want you to go ahead and confess just your top five sins. It’s just us. It’s fine. It’s a safe place.
Chris: Mike, give him an example of how that works. Take us through your top five.
Mike: You guys heard that, right? That was really from the heart.
Chris: So we’re brave here, Chris.
Mike: Yeah, we are. Whenever you’re ready. Just take your time.
Chris Clayton: Wow. What was the first question, Chris?
Chris: That mouthful of a question: how do you deal with doubt and discomfort and stay aligned with God during those times?
Chris Clayton: I don’t know. Short answer. No. I feel like it’s a daily wrestling match. Even in a year that’s been, professionally, a great year, there have still been some personal things and struggles with our family. There’s a new rhythm of life, being that we’ve completely uprooted our family out of a church that we were entrenched in for six and a half years, into a brand new church, a new rhythm of life, a new studio space, and new relationships. So I feel like our emotions have already been on high alert because of just that. And when the enemy sees that, he pounces on it a little bit. That’s caused a lot of doubt for me as a husband and as a father, going, “Did I make the right decision?” While everything seems to be going great career-wise, up and to the right on the chart, there’s still always the behind the scenes. Our family is doing well, but there are things that have been tough to walk through over the last year. If there’s anything I’ve wrestled with in the last year, it’s doubt: did I make the right decision? I’ve talked that out with a lot of guys and gals that I trust in our circle, and Kara and I have talked it out. We know without a shadow of a doubt where we’re supposed to be, but that doesn’t make it any easier to walk through day by day. Every day is getting up, staying consistent in the Word, and asking Him, “Lord, would You align my path with the people we need to be aligned with, and give us blinders for things we don’t need to be in association with?” Not because they’re bad, but because they’re just not for us at the moment. “And give us confidence that we’re walking in the right way every single day.” Doubt’s probably been the biggest struggle over the last 10 or 11 months since making that decision. And that thing’s reared its head all through my life, even after moving to Nashville, when it was like, okay, we’re here, I’ve got one record on my calendar over the next six months, did we make the right decision? And honestly, this is a whole other thing, but doubt gets erased when I start looking at my kids and my family and seeing them thrive in a decision I had to make as the leader of the home. I think about my son Corbin, who would not be where he’s at as a lighting director for a band, traveling and touring. He wouldn’t have gotten that opportunity unless we had moved here to Nashville. We would not have found our daughter, Kambree, if we had not taken the faith step to move here. It’s little things like that that affirm, okay, this was the right thing. Even though I wrestle with the doubt sometimes, I know where we’re supposed to be.
Mike: Yeah. Proverbs 16:9 is becoming more of a banner verse for me, maybe over the past decade, moving to different cities and doing different initiatives that we feel like God’s called us to do: “The heart of man plans his way, but the Lord establishes his steps.” I don’t know if y’all feel this way, but the older I get, the more I feel like that really does dwindle down to each day, even to segments of the day. Culturally, I feel like I’m told the opposite. The older I get, the more I should have the next 30 years coasting and figured out. I feel like it’s dwindled down to, “Okay, God, just establish my steps for the next hour, and I’m going to trust You’re going to keep doing that.” Do y’all feel that? Chris, you sound like you’re saying that a little bit. Co-host Chris, I don’t know if you agree or not.
Chris: I’m not going to disagree with that, Mike. I wholeheartedly agree. As you get a little bit older in years, especially now that I’m hugging the AARP line, a little bit older than you… it’s going to fly by, I want to remind you. It’s going to fly by really quick, Mike, these next 10 years.
Mike: Thanks for saying that to me, like I’m the 10-year-old of the group.
Chris: But yes, everything counts, I would say. There’s not a day that you can really take off and say, “Okay, I’ve got it from here, God. Just leave me the keys.” I think you do get to a point where you rely more and more on the Lord, asking Him for His direction and letting Him establish those steps.
Chris Clayton: That’s been a key verse for our family over the years. People used to ask me, my mentors would ask me, “What is your five-year plan?” And I didn’t realize how much I hated that question until I got older. I’m like, I don’t know what I’m working on next week. Gosh, this year especially. It’s always just a daily dependence. There’s a great song called “Lord, I Need You.” It’s an old hymn that was adapted into a modern worship chorus, and it’s been such a banner song over the years, because it’s such a confession. The bridge says, “Teach my song to rise to You.” Like, everything that I do, point to You. Just dependence. What are you doing in five years, guys?
Mike: Oh, yeah. I definitely have all that figured out. Let me just go pull it. I’ve got to scroll right here.
Chris: It’ll be a five-year checkup with Chris Clayton on the podcast.
Chris Clayton: Yes. Check in with me in five years, guys. That’d be great.
Mike: It’s good you’re talking about music and the hymn, because let’s talk a little more about the music. Correct me, I’m sure I’m going to get this wrong. I want to say three decades’ worth of experience, give or take…
Chris Clayton: I’m coming up on 2.5.
Mike: Okay. 2.5. That’s not confusing at all. 2.5 decades’ worth of experience in worship leading. And Chris has seen this along with me: you have a genuine pastoral heart for people, and you’re an excellent leader. I can attest to this personally, so you’re just going to have to accept the compliment. You handle the stage and leading people, publicly and privately, with such good care. You genuinely care for people. You have a pastoral heart that comes out of you even now. And you’ve been in this world of the music industry, which sometimes crosses over into people thinking entertainment industry. There are a lot of people who say, “I want to do music. I want to write. I want to perform. I want to play this instrument. I’m going to be a worship pastor someday.” I know this might be a big question, but for someone pursuing something similar out there, what are some common myths they should dismiss, and some truths they should really consider?
Chris Clayton: Hmm. That’s a great question. Thank you.
Chris: Yes, Mike. That was a well-crafted question.
Chris Clayton: Well crafted.
Mike: Thank you. Thank you, Christian.
Chris Clayton: One thing that comes to mind, and I’ll give you some practical and hopefully think of some spiritual… For what I do as a producer and songwriter these days, there’s a big myth that you have to go to school for it, formal education. A lot of great songwriters and producers in this town have done that. But I can think of some right now who are producing some of the stuff you’re hearing on Christian radio, and they never even went to school outside of high school. They took a risk. They moved to a town like Nashville and got entrenched in the culture. I think the barrier to entry for what I do is so much lower than it was even 10 years ago. The gear you can buy is a lot more accessible. The mere fact that I can make a record on a laptop with a microphone and a small interface and be just as competitive as whatever else is out there… that’s how records are being made. There are kids in bedrooms making records right now that you’re hearing on the radio. More than anything, it’s investing in the gear, but it’s also investing in relationships and building relationships. They call Nashville anywhere from a seven- to 10-year town just to get started. You can’t just move to a place like Nashville and expect it to happen in a year or two. I’m sure some guys and gals have, but the odds are against that. I’m eight years into it, and there are just now songwriters and artists I’ve wanted to write with that I’m able to start getting into the room with. There are just now relationships, and trust in those relationships, coming about by being consistent and showing up. So it takes time. The myth is, “I have to go to school, and if I go to school, I’m going to graduate with a degree and have everything I need to get this career going.” That’s just not true. You can definitely go to school and learn a lot. But the bigger investment is entrenching yourself in a culture and making a lot of bad records and writing a lot of bad songs to get better at it. Was it Gladwell who said there’s a 10,000-hour principle? That’s really true: putting those 10,000 hours into your craft, because it just takes that long to get good at it. It took me forever to feel confident at it. And now it’s taking confidence and building on it to where I feel like I can deliver what I need to deliver every day. Not everything’s a home run, but it’s still a journey. There are guys and gals grinding out every single day, just like me, to do this. And maybe another myth: I haven’t felt this town be very competitive between songwriters and producers and artists. Maybe it’s the circle I run in, but I feel more community than competition. I’ve borrowed gear from other producers, and other producers have borrowed gear from me. We all do the same thing and try to make a living. So I think that’s probably the biggest myth. Maybe the other one would be that you have to move to Nashville to do it. I don’t think you have to. I think it’s important, but I know a lot of artists and songwriters who don’t live here and have made a living doing this. It certainly helps, but it’s not a must-have. It depends on your stage of life. When I moved to Nashville with four kids and a wife, I couldn’t take the same risk as a 20-year-old with no family. If I were 20 years old again, maybe. But the Lord moved us at the right time for us.
Mike: Do you think some people want to get into music for the wrong reasons, because it’s cool? What are some of the people you’ve seen come in, where you meet with them and you’re like, “I don’t know”? Is it the unwillingness to put in 10,000 hours? Can you speak to the motivation a little bit?
Chris Clayton: I’ve definitely hung out with a lot of young artists and producers who just like the flashiness of this type of thing and the flashiness of the city. And it really is not that flashy of a city, if I’m honest with you, but it’s the allure of it. And then I’ve met with artists and producers who you can genuinely see have their hearts in the right place, but they also know what they want as an artist or as a producer. They have goals, and they’re driven not to make it, but to make an impact in what they’re doing. There’s a major difference in the maturity level of an artist when you see them come in with “How do I do this?” versus “How do I do this, because this is what I want to do?” They’re easy to spot. They’re easy to sniff out. And with my time, I’d rather invest in the “How do I do this, because this is what I want to do” type of people.
Chris: That’s good. I can see how that community focus could be helpful, not just in song production or songwriting, but also in business or anything that people out there listening want to take a chance on, thinking, “This road seems like it’s going to be a tough road, and I don’t know if there’s a clear-cut instruction on how to get there.” But by investing in other people, and having them invest in you, having community can really help move you down the road and give you some people for the journey. It sounds like that’s been really helpful to you.
Chris Clayton: Yeah. You hit something that I always tell people. I love doing this. I get hit up a lot by young artists just to have coffee and hang out, and I love that.
Mike: Let me know whenever you’re available for us to go have coffee. I sent you that DM.
Chris Clayton: I didn’t get it.
Chris: How come I wasn’t invited, Mike?
Mike: Oh, sorry.
Chris Clayton: Sorry. I got yours. Thank you.
Chris: Oh, Mike, you weren’t supposed to know about that. Young writers wanting to know the secrets of Chris?
Chris Clayton: What was I even going with all that? They always ask my story. They ask about my journey: “How did you get started in this?” Of course I’ll share my journey, but I always close it with, “My journey won’t be your journey.” Just because I did it this way won’t necessarily make it your path. There may be some similarities between friends, whether they’re artists or producers or whatever, but everybody’s journey that I’ve heard is always different. That’s the beauty of it. There’s never been a cookie-cutter way to do this. There’s no magic formula. I try to tell them that, and sometimes they look at me glazed over, like, “What do you mean there’s not a formula?” I’m like, there’s really not. I could take Chris Tomlin’s path verbatim, and that doesn’t mean I’m going to have the same success as Chris Tomlin as a songwriter.
Chris: With Christian music in general, of course there are songs we’re completely familiar with and artists we’re familiar with. Sometimes there are detractors to Christian music saying, “Well, some of it sounds the same,” or there are going to be critiques along the way. Not necessarily the case. And of course, you’re really close to a lot of the different artists who are coming out with new sounds, and you’re trying to produce new sounds. What are you excited about in Christian music? What’s moving the needle for you?
Chris Clayton: Two things come to mind. One, and I mean this in the utmost respectful way: radio has driven the Christian music format for decades, and it still drives it. Radio is not dead in Christian music. So many people say radio is dead, it’s going away. In fact, radio is probably the strongest it’s ever been in Christian music, and it drives so much of what creates Christian music culture, love it or hate it. That’s just how it is. It’s kind of a love-hate relationship when it comes to songwriting and artists and the label world. But what’s been fun to watch, especially over the last couple of months, is fringe artists getting on Christian radio who would not have been on it even 12 months ago. Here’s an example. There’s a great artist, Forrest Frank. He’s got this song called “Good Day.” It’s all over Christian radio right now. I know Mike listens to classical music all day long, so he probably won’t hear it.
Mike: Yeah.
Chris Clayton: I knew it. I knew it was Beethoven. But Forrest, and I’ll say this cautiously, I don’t believe he’s signed to a major Christian label. I think he’s an independent artist. But the song resonated so well on social media, like TikTok and Instagram stories, that he created this mass following on those platforms, which enabled him to make his own music of the same quality as other artists on the radio. I think it kind of forced radio’s hand, and I love it, because he’s paving the way for other underground artists, if you will, in Christian music to hopefully find a spot on Christian radio. Forever, an independent artist on Christian radio was nearly impossible. So to see that really excites me, as a guy who works with a lot of independent artists as well as label artists. It’s fun to say, “Hey, we have a shot with getting this song on there if you play your cards right.” There’s never a guarantee. And second, on the worship side of things, I’ve been so encouraged over the last four years or so to see the church return to singing vertical songs. What I mean by vertical is the “Holy, Holy, Holy” moment songs, “How Great Is Our God,” our heart to God’s heart, and not singing so much about “woe is me, I’m in the pit.” We need those songs, too. There’s a healthy balance. But I noticed even when I was leading at Gateway, our people just craved those songs coming out of COVID especially. We were already focused enough on our own issues and our own problems, swimming in our despair from being isolated for a year. So to see songs being written that come back to this more vertical “we lift Jesus high,” and to see worship leaders and churches wanting to lead those kinds of songs, really encourages my worship leader heart, because those songs will always win. If you look at the top 10 on CCLI, which is the chart that basically shows what songs churches are singing, I think well over 50, 60, 70% were vertical songs, just singing about the goodness of God, the greatness of God, His holiness, His majesty. And man, those are the legacy songs. Those are the songs I want to be a part of writing. You go through the hymnal, and you have “Holy, Holy, Holy.” You have “How Great Thou Art.” Those are the songs that have resonated in the church for hundreds of years. And as a songwriter, those are the kinds of songs I want to write and leave in the church.
Mike: I love that. I’m with you on the vertical. I pay more attention now to the lyrics. At first it was more the melody, and how the music makes me feel, and I’m starting to appreciate the lyrics a lot more. With vertical worship, when you say worship pastor, lots of different things come to people’s heads when they hear the role. There are a lot of different visuals there, and we can’t unpack all of those. But for you, how would you define a good worship pastor, a worship leader? What do you think their role is?
Chris Clayton: I think worship leader and worship pastor are two different things in my head. A worship leader can be very pastoral, but a worship pastor is going to be pastoral both on and off stage. They wear that title “pastor” for more than just a Sunday morning or a weekend service. They’re thinking about the shepherding aspect of the worship side of things, and not just being a song leader on a Sunday morning who opens up for the pastor. They’re trying to figure out how they can take their 30-minute allotment on a Sunday and leave a mark on the people they stand in front of, not just musically, but theologically and doctrinally, and help them grow in their faith. When I teach on songwriting, I always use a phrase I heard years ago: portable theology. Songs are about four minutes long on average these days, especially in worship, four or five minutes. And whether pastors like it or not, people are going to remember songs more than sermons, because of the way they’re written, with a catchy lyric or a hook or a melody. So songs had better be entrenched with great theology and doctrine, because people are going to take them out of their services on Sunday and sing them throughout the week. That’s what they’re designed to do. If they’re not rich in great theology and doctrine, then I failed my church as a worship pastor to give them something to chew on for the week. So as a worship pastor, you’re mindful that every single Sunday you stand on a platform, that four- or five-song set is in fact four or five mini sermons you’re imparting that day. You’re pastoring your people with those songs. But it’s also the idea that when junk hits the fan on Tuesday with one of the people in your church, you don’t pass the buck to the associate pastor. You’re just as in the trenches as they are, because you’re part of the shepherding team for that congregation.
Chris: I love that. And I would say that you fall into that category of worship pastor no matter what it looks like day to day. You definitely have the heart of a pastor, and you just happen to be really good at worship and song production and songwriting. So any would-be worship pastors out there, I hope you’re taking this to heart. You’re hearing from Chris Clayton, who’s done this for 25 years, it sounds like.
Mike: Christopher G. Allen Clayton.
Chris Clayton: That’s exactly right.
Mike: Don’t forget his full name, Christian.
Chris: Hey, we’re just glad to have you here today. I know it’s going to encourage people, whether they’re pursuing music or writing.
Chris Clayton: I’m trying to think of a good middle name for you, and I can’t think of one right now.
Mike: G. Allen is always a good go-to. Christian, do you think this would be a good time for a little bit of a transition here with our guest?
Chris: I think we put Clayton through the lightning round. What do you say?
Mike: Bring it on. Lightning round, everyone. Are you feeling strong? Are you feeling ready? Don’t overthink this. Okay, here we go. Intense moment. I’m going to scoot up to the mic for some intensity. If you could see any music artist in concert, who would you pick?
Chris Clayton: Okay. Pause.
Mike: No one in the history of the lightning round has ever paused the lightning round.
Chris Clayton: Is this people that I’ve seen before, or haven’t seen before?
Mike: I just want your top music artist in concert, man. You’re overthinking it. Just have fun with this.
Chris Clayton: Okay. Coldplay.
Mike: Oh, yes. Coldplay. Here we go. East Coast or West Coast?
Chris Clayton: East Coast.
Mike: Mountains or beach?
Chris Clayton: Mountains.
Chris: Motorcycle or jet ski?
Chris Clayton: Jet ski.
Chris: Greatest sports team ever assembled?
Chris Clayton: Oh, man. Well, the 2023 Texas Rangers.
Chris: Great answer.
Mike: Yes. Great answer.
Chris: Best pizza in Nashville, because you’re no longer here in Dallas on a regular basis, so we can’t ask about DFW.
Chris Clayton: Best pizza in Nashville. If other Nashville people hear this, they’re going to be like, “Nuh uh.” Pizza Hut. I’m just kidding. Okay. My friend’s place. He’s the guy that owns a restaurant down the road from here.
Mike: Okay. That’s great. Coffee or tea?
Chris Clayton: Tea.
Mike: Nashville Predators or Dallas Stars?
Chris Clayton: Preds.
Mike: Really? You’ve ditched the Stars, my friend. Okay. Sorry. I didn’t mean to judge you on that.
Chris Clayton: Just because the first year we were here, they went to the finals, and so we became fans.
Mike: That’s great. We’re happy to hear about that.
Chris: Wonderful story. Next.
Mike: Dogs or cats? Oh, this is going to be tough for your family. You have to pick one.
Chris Clayton: Dogs.
Chris: As a member of the “year of fitness” club, which we used to talk about starting every year, saying, “Hey, this is the year of fitness”… running or lifting?
Chris Clayton: Why?
Chris: Great answer. Favorite comedian?
Chris Clayton: Brian Regan.
Mike: Chris, you finish us off here with the last two biggest questions of your life.
Chris: If you were a superhero, who would you be? You can make up a superhero too. It doesn’t have to be one we know.
Chris Clayton: Ant-Man.
Mike: Didn’t see it. And finally, Chris, say it.
Chris: If someone were to narrate your life story, the Christopher G. Allen Clayton story, who would it be?
Chris Clayton: Matthew McConaughey.
Mike: Oh, well done. All right, all right, all right. Very good, my friend. Well, you are officially off of the hot seat. Thank you. I know you’ve got to rest and recover from that. Have a little dinner. Where can people find out about what you’re doing now online? I know you’ve also stepped into the coaching world on top of your production. Where can we point people?
Chris Clayton: The coaching thing, just as a side note, is something that’s been on my heart forever. And honestly, I’ve been scared to death to do it forever. It was a confidence thing. I just launched it, and my slots filled in less than 48 hours. So that was very affirming. Thank you. The website is chrisclaytonmusic.com. That’s for all things production, and there’s a link to the coaching there. We’ll do it again in 2025. I’ve already had enough inquiries about it that I was like, well, I guess we should do it again.
Chris: We’ll share that in the show notes.
Mike: It’s in there.
Chris Clayton: And then Instagram is where I hang out the most: Chris Clayton Music. I will reply to your DMs. That’s just how I am. I like doing that.
Mike: Except for mine, but everyone else.
Chris Clayton: Did you send the DM?
Chris: I think you got mine, though, right?
Chris Clayton: I got yours, Chris. Yeah.
Mike: For real, thank you for taking the time and sharing what we know is your 2.5-plus decades of experience. I remember, a long time ago when we first met, I really was like, “Man, we’re going to be buddies.” I don’t know how to describe it. We’re just going to be friends. And that’s been true for a long time now. Watching your obedience with your family, and with the people right in front of you, the way you’ve loved them well… you even helped us as a church plant in Austin, and it was some of the most effective worship we’ve had, and that was done virtually. If you can do that in front of a camera, you can do that in person. I think you really are a great example of, “Hey God, my hands are open. Establish my steps. Let me just be faithful to whatever You call me to do.” So just thank you for doing that. Thank you for taking time for us, even though sometimes we’re silly, especially co-host Chris. We just really value you and your time.
Chris Clayton: Yeah, man. I’ve been looking forward to it.
Chris: We’re thankful for you and blessed to know you and your family as well. The faith steps that you’ve taken together are a real testament to God and His grace, and to trusting Him. So keep it up, buddy.
Chris Clayton: Well, thank you, guys. You guys have been such an encouragement over the years, and we’re in this all together, even though we’re not quite there yet.
Mike: Oh, hey, you don’t have to cuss on the podcast. Wow. We’re sorry, everyone. We had to get that out of there.
Chris Clayton: You ruined a good thing, Mike.
Outro: Thanks so much for joining us. Please consider rating and reviewing our podcast and hitting subscribe on whichever platform you prefer. Remember to keep moving forward, because we’re not quite there.












